Bookmark and Share
Share

Library Items

8 Steps to Completing a Conservation Easement

The Tug Hill Tomorrow Land Trust provides landowners with a photo-rich, word-light, 11-page explanation of the 8 major steps required to establish a conservation easement to held by the land trust.
Rating
Last Modified
Feb 14, 2020
Viewed
1270 times

A Guided Tour of the Conservation Easement Enabling Statutes

2014
Organizations/Sources: Land Trust Alliance
First published in 2010 and updated in 2014, this report compares and contrasts the conservation easement enabling statutes enacted across the United States and discusses the key issues addressed and not addressed by these statutes.
Rating
Last Modified
Apr 19, 2016
Viewed
5691 times

A Tax Guide to Conservation Easements

2008
This is a comprehensive book on the tax benefits of the charitable contribution, or bargain sale, of a conservation easement. It provides a detailed explanation of the complex and extensive requirements of the federal tax code and related concepts, including the rules governing the operation of tax-exempt organizations such as land trusts.
Rating
Last Modified
Oct 27, 2015
Viewed
4858 times

A Time to Preserve: A Call for Formal Private-Party Rights in Perpetual Conservation Easements

2005
Organizations/Sources: Georgia Law Review
Brown presents her thesis that private parties should have a common law property interest in conservation easements sufficient to confer standing to seek injunctive relief. She briefly describes the history and rationales underlying the creation and perpetuation of conservation easements and the close relationship between preservation and a strong private property regime, discusses challenges to perpetual conservation easements under the doctrine of changed conditions as well as the importance of private-party standing to the defense of conservation easements, and considers efficiency and social justice arguments in favor of a restricted application of the doctrine of changed conditions. She demonstrates that decentralizing property ownership interests by enforcing property owners’ decisions to burden their property with perpetual conservation easements is consistent with a democratic property system.
Rating
Last Modified
Oct 27, 2015
Viewed
3587 times

Brandywine Conservancy Co-Holding Agreeement

Organizations/Sources: Brandywine Conservancy
Sample of Brandywine Conservancy's co-holding agreement for easements co-held with the county.
Rating
Last Modified
Feb 28, 2019
Viewed
1319 times

Capturing the Value of Appreciated Development Rights on Conservation Easement Termination

2006
Authors: James L. Olmsted
Organizations/Sources: Environmental Law and Policy Journal
This article explores conservation easement drafting strategies responsive to global warming and climate change. It proposes the development of an "Ark" easement, which unlike traditional, perpetual easements, would be terminable by the holder without resort to a judicial proceeding if global warming caused changes render the conservation purposes of the easement impossible or impractical. For this strategy to succeed, however, the easement holder must be able to recover the full, appreciated value of the development rights and redeploy them to further the social good of land and resource conservation.
Rating
Last Modified
Nov 11, 2010
Viewed
3704 times

Carbon Offsets in Conservation Easements: The Essentials for Land Trusts

2020
Organizations/Sources: Land Trust Alliance
This document offers guidance to land trust practitioners on drafting conservation easement granting documents to (1) allow the development of carbon offset projects; and (2) convey or clarify the ownership of the carbon offsets generated by such a project. 38 pages.
Rating
Last Modified
Jul 18, 2023
Viewed
200 times

Climate Surfing: A Conceptual Guide to Drafting Conservation Easements in the Age of Global Warming

2008
Authors: James L. Olmsted
In light of the changes global warming will bring, this article creates a case for the argument that upon any easement termination, it is the holder of a conservation easement that is entitled to the appreciated value of the development rights held in abeyance by a conservation easement. It addresses conservation easement provisions that would calculate and direct such appreciated value to the easement holder and that would also prevent the landowner from receiving an unwarranted windfall. Finally, it discuss a new type of conservation easement, an “ark” easement, which is intended to assist species and ecosystems in global warming caused migrations by being terminable at the easement holder’s option.
Rating
Last Modified
Oct 27, 2015
Viewed
3889 times

Conservation and Preservation Easements Act

2001
Organizations/Sources: Commonwealth of Pennsylvania
The Pennsylvania Conservation and Preservation Easements Act, the act of June 22, 2001 (P.L. 390, No. 29) (32 P.S. §§5051-5059) was enacted in its final form as House Bill 975, PN 2294. It is Pennsylvania's enabling act for conservation easements (excluding agricultural conservation easements created under the Agricultural Area Security Law.)
Rating
Last Modified
Oct 27, 2015
Viewed
11530 times

Conservation Defense Insurance

2008
Organizations/Sources: Land Trust Alliance
The goal of the Conservation Defense Insurance is to create favorable case law, avoid unfavorable case law, defend and enforce conservation easements, protect fee-owned land, encourage practices that will help prevent violations and unnecessary litigation, support good practices, and provide the confidence and capability to uphold conservation obligations forever.
Rating
Last Modified
Apr 04, 2011
Viewed
4181 times

Conservation Drafting & Documentation

2009
Organizations/Sources: Pregmon Law Offices
Presentation focusing on Conservation Easement Drafting.
Rating
Last Modified
Aug 21, 2018
Viewed
4733 times

Conservation Easements

2002
A 3-page article covering easement basics. Published by the National Association of Legal Assistants.
Rating
Last Modified
Mar 24, 2011
Viewed
4591 times

Conservation Easements: An Introduction for Private Landowners

2018
Authors: Andrew M. Loza
A conservation easement limits certain uses of the land in order to advance one or more conservation objectives while keeping the land in the owner’s control. It is established by mutual agreement of a landowner and a private land trust or government. (WeConservePA guide; 5 pages)
Rating
Last Modified
Jul 01, 2021
Viewed
5835 times

Conservation Easements--A Troubled Adolescence

2005
This article briefly describes conservation easements and how they operate to protect the conservation values of land, describes the dramatic growth in the use of conservation easements over the past two and a half decades, and highlights some of the more troubling issues that have arisen as a result of the growth in the use of easements, as well as proposals for reform. The article asserts that if reforms can be successfully implemented, conservation easements can emerge from their troubled adolescence to take their appropriate adult role in the panoply of land conservation techniques, and may help lead us to a new paradigm of private property ownership.
Rating
Last Modified
Jul 18, 2012
Viewed
3818 times

Conservation Easements at the Climate Change Crossroads

2011
Study examining perpetual conservation easements in light of a changing climate. What happens when a conservation easement sets rules pertaining to the treatment of a landscape on a property (i.e., coastline) that may drastically change or even disappear due to climate change?
Rating
Last Modified
Apr 11, 2019
Viewed
1357 times

Conservation Easements Guide

Organizations/Sources: Brandywine Conservancy
Rating
Last Modified
Oct 15, 2010
Viewed
3779 times

Conservation Easements in Court: A Review of Easement Violation and Enforcement Litigation in Pennsylvania

2020
A review of Pennsylvania judicial decisions reveals that conservation easement holders and the conservation values they uphold prevail when a dispute leads to litigation. Courts respect the text of easement documents and their conservation purposes. This guide reviews eleven cases where the interpretation or enforcement of a conservation easement was at the center of litigation. 11 pages
Rating
Last Modified
Nov 27, 2020
Viewed
1613 times

Conservation Easements in Private Practice

2010
Authors: Shea B. Airey
This article presents an overview of conservation easements designed to help practitioners reap the myriad benefits that state and federal law authorize. It addresses three distinct subjects pertaining to conservation easements; an account of the development of conservation easements; an in-depth review of conservation easement tax law and examples of potential tax benefits; and the often-altruistic client motivations that drive the conservation easement field.
Rating
Last Modified
Nov 11, 2010
Viewed
3284 times

Conservation Easements: Now More Than Ever - Overcoming Obstacles to Protect Private Lands

2004
Authors: Adam E. Draper
Organizations/Sources: Environmental Law
This article discusses the history of conservation easements up to the present, and analyzes several barriers preventing even broader use of this valuable private land protection instrument. It alerts landowners and easement holders to several legal and policy concerns creating barriers to the effectiveness and appeal of conservation easements and investigates available and potential resolutions to these concerns.
Rating
Last Modified
Oct 27, 2015
Viewed
3878 times

Conservation Easements: Ohio State University Fact Sheet

1998
Organizations/Sources: Ohio State University
This fact sheet answers a number of frequently asked basic questions about conservation easements.
Rating
Last Modified
Oct 27, 2015
Viewed
4814 times

Conservation Easements: Perpetuity and Beyond

2007
Organizations/Sources: Ecology Law Quarterly
In this article, McLaughlin outlines the support for applying charitable trust principles to perpetual conservation easements, including uniform laws, the Restatement of Property, federal tax law, and case activity on this issue to date. She cautions that perpetual land protection is not appropriate in all circumstances and recommends a more considered use of perpetual conservation easements as a land protection tool. This article explores the possible use of a number of nonperpetual conservation easements to accomplish land protection goals.
Rating
Last Modified
Oct 27, 2015
Viewed
4173 times

Conservation Options: A Landowner's Guide

2003
Organizations/Sources: Land Trust Alliance
Guide outlines various conservation options for landowners, including conservation easements, donating land, and more.
Rating
Last Modified
Jun 22, 2018
Viewed
2098 times

Costs of the Easement Planning Process: Landowner Benefits and Land Trust Risks

2011
Authors: Bill Hutton
Conservation transactions may involve substantial planning and execution costs. Some of those expenses clearly benefit one or the other party to the transaction. Who benefits from other expenses may be quite ambiguous. Accurate assignment of financial responsibility for these various transactional expenses has both economic and tax consequences for the landowner as well as implications for the conservation organization. 4 pp.
Rating
Last Modified
Apr 06, 2011
Viewed
4719 times

Court and IRS Decisions Affecting Easement Drafting

2016
The documents provided here were touched on at the 10/28/16 seminar on "Drafting Easement Documents to Minimize Stewardship Pain: 21 Crucial Decisions"
Rating
Last Modified
Aug 21, 2018
Viewed
3178 times

Deed Restriction Versus Conservation Easement

2021
In most circumstances, a conservation easement is a far better tool for conserving land than a deed restriction. This guide explains how the tools differ. [WeConservePA guide; 4 pages]
Rating
Last Modified
Jun 15, 2021
Viewed
1673 times

Delineating Conservation Easement Boundaries and Protection Areas

2021
Properly delineating the boundaries of conservation easements and their different protection areas is crucial to easement stewardship and enforcement. Conservation restrictions are difficult, if not impossible, to enforce unless tied to physical locations on the ground. This guide discusses the delineation of boundaries and protection areas using physical markers, verbal descriptions, and visual depictions. [7-page WeConservePA guide]
Rating
Last Modified
Mar 19, 2021
Viewed
1521 times

Dynamic Conservation Easements: Facing the Problem of Perpetuity in Land Conservation

2005
Authors: Duncan Greene
Organizations/Sources: Seattle University Law Review
This article examines the “dynamic conservation easement”, an easement whose terms provide land use restrictions that may change over time. It argues they are better suited to serving their unique conservation purposes and are more likely to fulfill their promise to protect the land in perpetuity than static conservation easements, whose terms provide unchanging land use restrictions.
Rating
Last Modified
Nov 11, 2010
Viewed
5035 times

Ensuring Sustainable Forestry Through Working Forest Conservation Easements in the Northeast

2006
Organizations/Sources: Forest Guild
Conservation easements can be designed to ensure sustainable forestry and safeguard important public values. This 54 page report includes a survey of three working forest conservation easements and evaluates how well each easement and its related documents ensures sustainable forestry.
Rating
Last Modified
Oct 29, 2015
Viewed
4245 times

Exacted Conservation Easements: The Hard Case of Endangered Species Protection

2004
As part of the process a landowner must undergo when seeking to develop land where either federally listed endangered or threatened species, or their habitat, are present, the landowner must prepare a Habitat Conservation Plan. It has become commonplace for government agencies to require the creation of conservation easements as part of these plans. This article describes the use of conservation easements in the Habitat Conservation Plan process under the Endangered Species Act and explains the complexities that arise with the enforcement of those conservation easements.
Rating
Last Modified
Oct 29, 2015
Viewed
4339 times

Federal Tax Deductibility of Conservation Easement Donations

2021
Some donations of conservation easements qualify for a federal income tax deduction; others do not.
Rating
Last Modified
Feb 06, 2021
Viewed
3171 times

Forever and Ever, Amen: Land Trusts and the Frightening Thought of Perpetuity

2010
Authors: Tim Findley
Organizations/Sources: Range Magazine
Findley gives a brief overview of the land conservation movement in the United States and the use of conservation easements. He gives several examples of how conservation easements have successfully allowed landowners to protect their land.
Rating
Last Modified
Oct 29, 2015
Viewed
3665 times

Funding Conservation Easement Stewardship: Your Role as the Land's Owner and Conservation Champion

2022
Authors: Andrew M. Loza
In accepting a conservation easement from you, the land trust takes on the responsibility of ensuring that the land is conserved as you have agreed for all time. Fulfilling this duty requires financial resources most likely to come from you or subsequent owners of the land. (print version of WeConservePA guide, 2 pp.)
Rating
Last Modified
Apr 17, 2022
Viewed
949 times

General Guidelines for Conservation Easement Projects

2011
Organizations/Sources: Brandywine Conservancy
This document was developed by Brandywine Conservancy to share with prospective landowners and explain the many important legal and financial issues that a prospective easement donor should consider.
Rating
Last Modified
Nov 04, 2015
Viewed
4768 times

Guide to the Conservation and Preservation Easements Act: Pennsylvania Act 29 of 2001

2016
Conservation organizations can avoid many potential difficulties in conservation easement stewardship by ensuring that their conservation easement documents are drafted to conform with the Conservation and Preservation Easements Act.
Rating
Last Modified
Aug 31, 2017
Viewed
8231 times

Highlights from Terrafirma Aggregate Data

2011
Key takeaways from Terrafirma easement defense data between 2000 and 2011.
Rating
Last Modified
Jan 08, 2020
Viewed
1280 times

Highlights of the new restatement (third) of property: Servitudes

2000
Authors: Susan F. French
Organizations/Sources: Probate and Trust Journal
The author provides an overview of the modern law of servitudes and surveys the changes to traditional servitudes law brought about by the 2000 Restatement (Third) of Property: Servitudes. The author explains how the new Restatement simplifies and clarifies this body of law, providing greater freedom to property owners while safeguarding the public interest
Rating
Last Modified
Oct 29, 2015
Viewed
5466 times

Historic Green Springs v. Louisa County Water Authority

2011
United States District Court for the Western District of Virginia found that The Historic Green Springs, Inc. -- a holder of a conservation easement -- has standing under the Clean Water Act as a plaintiff regarding discharge of wastewater into a creek whose protection is a subject of the easement and an interest of the organization. (2011 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 70515)
Rating
Last Modified
Oct 29, 2015
Viewed
4966 times

Holders, Beneficiaries and Backup Grantees: Defining Roles and Relationships to Achieve Conservation Easement Objectives

2013
A conservation easement may have one or more holders responsible for upholding the easement’s conservation objectives. It may have a beneficiary, an entity with some rights to manage the easement in furtherance of the conservation objectives but no responsibility to do so. It may also provide a contingency plan to replace a holder in the event the holder cannot or will not perform its duties. Effective long-term easement management requires that when more than one entity shares easement management rights, the relationship between the entities must be carefully delineated.
Rating
Last Modified
Apr 28, 2017
Viewed
4945 times

Increasing the Tax Incentives for Conservation Easement Donations

2004
Organizations/Sources: Ecology Law Quarterly
This article undertakes a critical analysis of the tax incentives that encourage the donation of conservation easements and the proposals to increase them. It concludes that a responsible approach to increasing the tax incentives is called for: Congress should increase the incentives only if some assurance can be had that the increase will be efficient, that land trusts and government agencies have the expertise and resources to appropriately screen and steward the anticipated additional easements, and that the increase will not encourage exploitation and abuse.
Rating
Last Modified
Jul 18, 2012
Viewed
3210 times

Land Management Restrictions and Options for Change in Perpetual Conservation Easements

2013
Authors: Adena R. Rissman
Conservation organizations rely on conservation easements for diverse purposes, including protection of species and natural communities, working forests, and open space. This research investigated how perpetual conservation easements incorporated property rights, responsibilities, and options for change over time in land management. Many conservation easements involved significant constraints on easement holders’ options for altering land management to achieve conservation purposes over time. This study suggests the need for greater attention to easement drafting, monitoring, and ongoing decision processes to ensure the public benefits of land conservation in changing landscapes.
Rating
Last Modified
Apr 11, 2019
Viewed
1123 times

LandSavers, Conservation Easements

Authors: John Laird, PLS
Organizations/Sources: Heritage Conservancy and GreenWorks Media Center
This "Beyond Basics: Easements Part II" webcast delves into conservation easements, providing information on municipal land protection programs, financial benefits to landowners, steps in acquiring easements, and easement stewardship.
Rating
Last Modified
Oct 29, 2015
Viewed
5705 times

Land Trust Defense and Enforcement of Conserved Areas

2010
Achieving conservation goals in protected areas hinges on continual monitoring, enforcement, and legal defense. A national survey of land trust legal defense of conserved areas showed half of land trusts reported a legal challenge, and one-quarter of those land trusts were hindered by financial barriers in pursuing a legal challenge. Interviews with land trust staff revealed the necessary conditions for pursuing legal defense, including organizational capacity, community support, and persuasive property claims, as well as the importance of stewardship endowments and the need for greater land trust capacity and accountability.
Rating
Last Modified
Oct 29, 2015
Viewed
4389 times

LTA Fact Sheet - Co-holding Conservation Easement

Organizations/Sources: Land Trust Alliance
This document is one of a series of fact sheets and reference materials produced by the Land Trust Alliance. This fact sheet addresses the benefits of co-holding partnerships.
Rating
Last Modified
Oct 29, 2015
Viewed
3932 times

Model Assignment of Grant of Conservation Easement and Declaration of Covenants

2021
The Model Assignment of Grant of Conservation Easement and Declaration of Covenants with Commentary is a tool for transferring conservation easements and associated responsibilities, as well as related documents and stewardship funding, to other responsible organizations.
Rating
Last Modified
Nov 30, 2021
Viewed
1623 times

Model Consent, Non-Disturbance, and Subordination Agreement with Commentary, 2nd edition

2018
When a mortgage precedes an easement on a property, the possibility that one day the mortgage could be foreclosed poses a threat to the continued existence of the easement unless the holder of the mortgage signs an agreement that allows the easement to survive a foreclosure. In addition, "subordination" is necessary if a tax deduction will be sought for an easement donation. This model legal document provides a vehicle to satisfy both of these issues. Be sure to download both the model and the commentary.
Rating
Last Modified
Nov 18, 2022
Viewed
17970 times

Model Conservation Easement

2017
Authors: Andrew M. Loza
(print edition of ConservationTools.org guide) The Model Grant of Conservation Easement and Declaration of Covenants with Commentary provides users with a state-of-the-art legal document and guidance to customize it to nearly any situation. No easement document has benefited from more real-world testing and peer review.
Rating
Last Modified
Aug 31, 2017
Viewed
6834 times

Model Conservation Easement Donation Agreement with Commentary

2017
The Model Conservation Easement Donation Agreement helps land trusts avoid getting stuck with unreimbursed major expenses if a would-be easement donor walks away from a project. It outlines the steps to completing a project and the responsibilities of the land trust and donor. It also helps the parties avoid common misunderstandings.
Rating
Last Modified
May 19, 2018
Viewed
19478 times

Model Declaration of Public Trust with Commentary

2018
This set of model documents and accompanying commentary helps local governments to formally dedicate lands to public purposes and clarify what are and aren’t appropriate uses of the land. (The materials include an option to grant a conservation easement to a qualified holder as added protection for the land.)
Rating
Last Modified
Aug 21, 2022
Viewed
7285 times

Model Grant of Conservation Easement and Declaration of Covenants

2005
The Model Grant of Conservation Easement and Declaration of Covenants provides users with a state-of-the-art legal document together with an expansive commentary. Built on practitioner experiences and feedback, no easement document in the nation has benefited from more cycles of peer review. Download both the model and the commentary. The commentary explains the reasoning behind every provision, instructs on use of the model, and provides a wealth of alternative and optional provisions. The model was last updated in November 2021.
Rating
Last Modified
Nov 08, 2021
Viewed
54370 times

Model Stewardship Cost Calculator

2017
TEMPORARILY OUT OF SERVICE. DO NOT USE POSTED SPREADSHEET. Land trusts can use this tool to estimate the annual costs of stewardship for a conservation easement and the initial investment in a stewardship fund that will be needed to cover the costs. The calculator can be adapted to the needs of an individual land trust and to the specifics of a conservation easement. The guide "Costs of Conservation Easement Stewardship" (http://conservationtools.org/guides/86) explains many of the features and choices made in the calculator.
Rating
Last Modified
Jun 11, 2021
Viewed
18596 times

Model Stewardship Funding Covenant with Commentary

2012
Used to secure payment of deferred contributions and other conservation commitments made by present landowners and to be paid by either them or future owners. The model offers ten basic ways to structure stewardship funding arrangements in conjunction with conservation easement projects. Download both the model and the commentary.
Rating
Last Modified
Sep 17, 2018
Viewed
15911 times

Not a Charitable Trust: The Donated Conservation Easement in Pennsylvania

2022
Little evidence exists to support the proposition that a donated conservation easement, in the absence of a charitable trust agreement, is a charitable trust in Pennsylvania; indeed, there is compelling evidence to the contrary. (Holder covenants may be used to buttress easements and do not run into the legal obstacles or suffer from the policy failings of the trust proposition.) WeConservePA guide. 11 pages.
Rating
Last Modified
Sep 19, 2022
Viewed
4581 times

Not a Public Trust: The Land Trust-Held Conservation Easement in Pennsylvania

2023
No legal precedent exists in Pennsylvania for finding that a conservation easement acquired by a private land trust is a public trust.
Rating
Last Modified
Jun 30, 2023
Viewed
4938 times

Perpetual Trusts, Conservation Servitudes, and the Problem of the Future

2006
Authors: Susan F. French
Organizations/Sources: Cardozo Law Review
Private wealth-protecting perpetual trusts and environment-protecting conservation servitudes share the problem that both are long-term property arrangements that are likely to last far longer than the ability of their creators to predict what the future will bring. Existing doctrines can be used and extended to solve many problems that are likely to arise, but more will be needed. For conservation servitudes, more attention should be given to protecting the public interest against collusive terminations by action of a developer and the servitude holder and against retention of conservation servitudes of marginal value when the land is needed for other uses of benefit to the community.
Rating
Last Modified
Nov 11, 2010
Viewed
3389 times

Perpetuity, Latent Ancillary Rights, and Carbon Offsets in Global Warming Era

2009
Authors: James L. Olmsted
Organizations/Sources: Environmental Law Reporter
This article makes two recommendations regarding the drafting of conservation easements in the age of global warming. The first recommendation relates to drafting language that will ensure perpetuity in conservation easements where the eased land has been adversely affected by global warming. The second recommendation relates to drafting conservation easement language that addresses “latent ancillary rights” in the eased land that pertain to global warming, for example the carbon sequestration process in forested land.
Rating
Last Modified
Oct 29, 2015
Viewed
4330 times

Pre-Existing Mortgages in Easement Transactions: Using Non-Disturbance and Subordination Agreements to Prevent Extinguishment and Comply with Tax Law

2023
When a mortgage predates an easement on a property, the easement could be extinguished in a foreclosure if the owners default on their mortgage payments. And if the easement is to be donated and the donors wish to obtain tax benefits, additional complications arise. These problems can be avoided by obtaining an agreement from the mortgage holder appropriate to the circumstances. WeConservePA guide. 9 pages.
Rating
Last Modified
Feb 16, 2023
Viewed
9634 times

Private Conservation Easements

2009
Authors: Gerald Korngold
Organizations/Sources: Lincoln Institute of Land Policy
Conservation easements have permitted the leverage of private initiative, resources, and commitment to ensure that open space and wildlife habitats are preserved for future generations. At the same time though, private conservation easements raise public policy concerns related to the tax subsidies, the absence of public process in their creation, long-term stewardship, and flexibility to adapt conserved land to emerging needs of the community. This article examines the recent achievements and benefits of conservation easements, and suggests some reforms that might make them an even stronger vehicle for land conservation in the public interest.
Rating
Last Modified
Nov 11, 2010
Viewed
3313 times

Private Land Conservation in the Face of Climate Change

2013
Authors: Adena R. Rissman
Researchers from six universities across the country reached out to the land conservation community to learn how organizations are addressing climate change, if at all, and to assess the effectiveness of conservation easements in the face of a changing climate. The white paper suggests five strategies conservation organizations can follow to continue effectively protecting land in a changing climate.
Rating
Last Modified
Apr 11, 2019
Viewed
1917 times

Protecting the Public Interest and Investments in Conservation: A Response to Professor Korngold's Critique of Conservation Easements

2008
Organizations/Sources: Utah Law Review
McLaughlin and Machlis offer a rebuttal to Gerald Korngold’s article “Solving the Contentious Issues of Private Conservation Easements: Promoting Flexibility for the Future and Engaging the Public Land Use Process”, which presents a critique of conservation easements and a variety of suggestions for reform. They discuss five misconceptions that tend to pervade the criticism of conservation easements and result in proposals for reform that would be contrary to the public interest. They also discuss three of the primary reforms suggested in Korngold’s article and why they feel those reforms are both unnecessary and inadvisable.
Rating
Last Modified
Nov 11, 2010
Viewed
4335 times

Public Access to Information On Private Land Conservation: Tracking Conservation Easements

2010
Organizations/Sources: Wisconsin Law Review
State and federal governments face important choices about how to provide public access to conservation easement information, given growing concerns that the public’s substantial investment in conservation easements will be lost without comprehensive tracking over the long term. This article reflects on the public nature of conservation easements, the challenges posed by their perpetuity, and provides concrete recommendations for legislatures seeking to improve conservation easement tracking.
Rating
Last Modified
Nov 11, 2010
Viewed
3931 times

Randal A. Schrimsher et ux. v. Commissioner

2011
Organizations/Sources: United States Tax Court
In Randal A. Schrimsher et ux. v. Commissioner; T.C. Memo. 2011-71; No. 945-09 (27 Mar 2011), the U.S. Tax Court determined that a claimed deduction of $705,000 for a façade easement would be denied due to a lack of a contemporaneous written acknowledgement.
Rating
Last Modified
Oct 29, 2015
Viewed
6102 times

Reconciling Development and Natural Beauty: The Promise and Dilemma of Conservation Easements

2010
Authors: Zachary Bray
Organizations/Sources: Harvard Environmental Law Review 119
Contemporary conservation easement practice has attracted many critics, based in part on well-publicized national scandals involving fraudulent donations of conservation easements for tax purposes and in part on more general concerns about the potential inefficiency of these easements. This article scrutinizes the current debate by examining various criticisms and proposals for reform of current conservation easement practice. It provides important detail on contemporary conservation easement practice, considers the interaction between contemporary practice and the abstract concerns raised in the academic debate, and offers some suggestions for reform and further study.
Rating
Last Modified
Nov 11, 2010
Viewed
3788 times

Reinventing Conservation Easements: A Critical Examination and Ideas for Reform

2005
Authors: Jeff Pidot
Organizations/Sources: Lincoln Institute of Land Policy
Part One of this report provides an introduction to some of the issues arising from conservation easements, as foretold at the time of the enactment of the federal laws that granted them tax subsidies. Part One also describes the reasons why the public has a stake in conservation easements and in their content and governance. Part Two provides a Primer on Land Trusts and Conservation Easements, including defining terms, providing historical context and reporting current trends and a preview of the future problems that they present. Part Three specifically discusses issues emanating from conservation easements and evaluates a number of alternative ways to resolve them.
Rating
Last Modified
Oct 29, 2015
Viewed
4771 times

Representing Non-Concurrent Generations: The Problem of Now

2008
Authors: James L. Olmsted
This article is a rebuttal the position of Professor Julia D. Mahoney that conservation easements should not be allowed to remain in effect in perpetuity and instead they should be time limited, or perhaps not created in the first instance. The article provides a brief discussion of the historical and philosophical antecedents of real property law in the United States, an historical and legal analysis explaining how conservation easements fit within the current real property regime of the United States, and expounds upon the merits of perpetual conservation easements. The final parts of the article provide rebuttal to critiques Mahoney has provided to this work.
Rating
Last Modified
Nov 11, 2010
Viewed
3416 times

Restatement Third, Property (Servitudes): select sections

2000
Organizations/Sources: American Law Institute
This restatement is not statutory law but common law, which is court made law as result of prior court opinions.
Rating
Last Modified
Oct 29, 2015
Viewed
15474 times

Restraint on Alienation

Organizations/Sources: thefreedictionary.com
Definition of restraint on alienation from thefreedictionary.com with examples n. an attempt in a deed or will to prevent the sale or other transfer of real property either forever or for an extremely long period of time. Such a restraint on the freedom to transfer property is generally unlawful and therefore, void or voidable (can be made void if an owner objects), since a present owner should not be able to tie the hands of future generations to deal with their property. This ban on a restraint on alienation (transfer) is called "the rule against perpetuities."
Rating
Last Modified
Aug 16, 2011
Viewed
3625 times

Rethinking the Perpetual Nature of Conservation Easements

2005
Organizations/Sources: Harvard Environmental Law Review
This article argues that the charitable trust doctrine of cy pres should apply to donated conservation easements and, if interpreted as suggested, can provide a principled means of modifying or extinguishing easements that have ceased to provide sufficient public benefits to justify their continued enforcement (or have even arguably become detrimental to the public). It states that the landowner should be permitted to exercise dead hand control over the use of the property encumbered by the easement, but only so long as the easement continues to provide benefits to the public sufficient to justify its enforcement.
Rating
Last Modified
Oct 29, 2015
Viewed
4099 times

Review of the Agricultural Conservation Easement Purchase Program

2008
Pursuant to Senate Resolution 2007-195, this is a 78 page report on the impacts of Pennsylvania's Agricultural Conservation Easement Purchase Program.
Rating
Last Modified
Oct 29, 2015
Viewed
4401 times

Riparian Buffer Protection Agreement

2011
A riparian buffer protection agreement limits activities on all or a portion of a property to advance conservation purposes while keeping the property in the control of the landowner.
Rating
Last Modified
Mar 22, 2018
Viewed
6148 times

Sample Co-Holding Agreement

Organizations/Sources: Natural Lands Trust
Sample agreement for co-holding an easement with another entity.
Rating
Last Modified
Mar 01, 2019
Viewed
1202 times

Stewardship Funding Arrangements: Options for Financing the Obligations of Conservation Easement Holders

2018
(print edition of ConservationTools.org guide) A landowner may agree to one or more funding arrangements that require the landowner or successive owners of an eased property to make one or more payments to the easement holder to support stewardship of the property. These arrangements may be customized to fit the stewardship demands created by the particular conservation easement and the financial circumstances of the owner.
Rating
Last Modified
Oct 19, 2018
Viewed
10371 times

The Conservation Easement: A Flexible Tool for Preserving Family Lands

1997
Organizations/Sources: Natural Lands Trust
An overview of conservation easements, including the basics of what a conservation easement is, the tax benefits of donating an easement, and the easement process at Natural Lands Trust.
Rating
Last Modified
Oct 29, 2015
Viewed
3708 times

The Conservation Easement Handbook

2005
Organizations/Sources: Land Trust Alliance and The Trust for Public Land
A guide for establishing and maintaining a conservation easement program, the handbook provides technical guidelines for drafting conservation easements-complete with case studies, sample documents and references to landmark court decisions. Originally published in 1988, this new edition draws on 17 years of land trust experience in completing easements. It includes practical how-to tips and checklists for land trust staff and board members; detailed drafting guidelines for attorneys; and many sample documents on a companion CD-ROM.
Rating
Last Modified
Feb 03, 2014
Viewed
7709 times

The Durability of Conservation Easements

2022
Authors: Andrew M. Loza
Landowners grant conservation easements to conservation organizations (“land trusts”) in perpetuity. The conservation objectives of the easement and the associated restrictions on how land can be used are intended to be permanent. Land trusts and their allies across the nation go to great lengths to ensure this permanence. 2 pages. [Print version of WeConservePA guide]
Rating
Last Modified
Feb 14, 2022
Viewed
1416 times

The Emergence of Exacted Conservation Easements

2005
Organizations/Sources: Nebraska Law Review
Exacted conservation easements are not donated or voluntarily sold, they are mitigation requirements for landowners seeking to fulfill goals other than land protection. This article outlines reasons why exacted conservation easements emerged and why they are such a popular tool. Because they don’t embody the freedom of contract associated with traditional conservation easements and often tie directly to regulation of property, they are a tool that directly conflicts with many of the goals that gave rise to their emergence.
Rating
Last Modified
Nov 11, 2010
Viewed
4020 times

The Nature of the Conservation Easement and the Document Granting It

2023
By statute and by common law interpretation, a conservation easement is a real estate interest and is governed by real estate law, in particular, the law of servitudes. This guide analyzes the nature of the conservation easement and the operation of the document granting the easement. It includes discussion of the mechanisms that assist in upholding the easement's conservation objectives in perpetuity. WeConservePA guide. 15 pages.
Rating
Last Modified
Jan 26, 2023
Viewed
5195 times

The Role of Land Trusts in Biodiversity Conservation on Private Lands

2002
Organizations/Sources: Idaho Law Review
This article explores the role land trusts and conservation easements can play in the protection of biodiversity on private lands.
Rating
Last Modified
Oct 29, 2015
Viewed
3988 times

The Trouble with Time: Influencing the Conservation Choices of Future Generations

2004
Organizations/Sources: Natural Resources Journal
Thompason scrutinizes Julia Mahoney’s article “Perpetual Restrictions on Land and the Problem of the Future”, to see whether conservation easements and other existing efforts to conserve land across generations are quite as troubling as she suggests. Thompson argues that by shifting the decision-making authority over future land uses from a single private landowner to a land trust or various segments or representatives of the public, it is less likely for the land to be developed but still leaved the ultimate decision to future generations. He explores justifications for why one generation may want to make future developments more difficult and asks how society should balance the potential benefits of perpetual conservation easements against the possible costs to future adaptability.
Rating
Last Modified
Nov 11, 2010
Viewed
3150 times

Tribes as Trustees Again

2007
These article are a two part series that explore tribal use of conservation trust mechanisms to assert traditional native prerogatives on privately held lands in the United States. Part I (The Emerging Tribal Role in the Conservation Trust Movement) presents this role as an interface between two separate movements: the Native environmental sovereignty movement, aimed at protecting environmental resources located off the reservations, and the conservation trust movement created in response to the deficiencies of environmental law. Part II (Evaluating Four Models of Tribal Participation in the Conservation Trust Movement) seeks to develop the tribal role by evaluating four models of native engagement according to criteria important to both native and non-native interests.
Rating
Last Modified
Oct 29, 2015
Viewed
4048 times

Uniform Conservation Easement Act

1981
This document was drafted by the National Conference of Commissioners on Uniform State Laws and recommended for enactment in all of the states of the union in 1981. All or portions of the Uniform Act were subsequently adopted in many states.
Rating
Last Modified
Sep 30, 2013
Viewed
5841 times

Using Conservation Easements to Preserve Open Space: A Guide for Pennsylvania's Municipalities

2002
This 43 page publication provides an overview of conservation easements and outlines the steps involved in acquiring easements. It describes how municipalities can acquire easements or work in partnerships with land trusts on easement acquisitions and easement stewardship.
Rating
Last Modified
Oct 29, 2015
Viewed
5716 times

What is a Conservation Easement?

2011
Draft for review and comment.
Rating
Last Modified
Apr 29, 2013
Viewed
4048 times

Who Has Standing? Conservation Easements in Pennsylvania Courts

2013
Who can assert claims and be heard in Pennsylvania’s courts if a dispute heats up over the management of a conservation easement?
Rating
Last Modified
Apr 28, 2017
Viewed
5657 times

Who May Get Involved in Conservation Easement Management Matters? A Consideration for Amendment of Pre-June 2001 Easements

2021
Authors: Andrew M. Loza
Occasionally a land trust will seek to amend a conservation easement. More often, the owners of land subject to an easement will ask for an amendment. In any case, the issue of who can insert themselves into easement management matters can be compelling reason for the parties to agree to an amendment if the easement was created in Pennsylvania prior to June 22, 2001. WeConservePA guide. 2 pages.
Rating
Last Modified
Oct 28, 2021
Viewed
1144 times

Your Loss Is Not My Benefit; Your Gain Is Not My Detriment: The Tenuous Link Between Value to Landowner and Value to Conservation in Easement Transactions

2020
Authors: Andrew M. Loza
How does decrease or increase in market value of land resulting from establishing or amending an easement relate to the conservation easement’s value? What do we mean when we refer to “value”? This guide explores these questions.
Rating
Last Modified
Oct 30, 2020
Viewed
1119 times