Protecting the Public Interest and Investments in Conservation: A Response to Professor Korngold's Critique of Conservation Easements

Home » Libraries » ConservationTools Library » Protecting the Public Interest and Investments in Conservation: A Response to Professor Korngold's Critique of Conservation Easements

Protecting the Public Interest and Investments in Conservation: A Response to Professor Korngold's Critique of Conservation Easements

Library Categories

Land Use Ordinances & Development Standards
- Agricultural Preservation
- Comprehensive Plans
- Conservation By Design
  - Case Studies
- Historic Preservation
  - Historic Preservation - General
  - Historic Preservation Ordinances
- Official Map
- Public (Mandatory) Dedication and Fees-in-Lieu Ordinances
- Recreation, Park and Open Space Plans
- Sign Ordinances
- Steep Slopes
- Timber Harvest Ordinances
- Transfer of Development Rights
- Transportation Planning
- Zoning for Solar and Wind Systems
- Other Zoning & Land Development Ordinances

Acquisition of Land & Easements
- Conservation Easements
  - Model Easements & Other Legal Documents
  - Baseline Documentation
  - Conservation Easement Amendment, Modification and Termination
  - Conservation Easement Implementation Guides
- Farmland Preservation
- Trail & Public Access Easements
- Appraisals
- Strategic Conservation Planning
- Survey & GPS
- Negotiation

Financing Conservation
- General Conservation Finance Guides
- Transfer Fees & Stewardship Contributions
- Private Finance
- Public Open Space Programs and Ballot Campaigns
  - Referenda Results
- Funding Programs

Stewardship of the Land
- Invasive Plant Species
  - Ecology
  - Identification and Control
  - Invasive Species in Pennsylvania
- Habitat & Wildlife Management
- Riparian Buffer
- Native Plant Species
- Stewardship of Eased Lands
- Survey & GPS

Case for Conservation
- Economic Benefits of Conservation
  - Economic Benefits of Biodiversity
  - Cost of Community Services
  - Economic Benefits of Ecosystem Services
  - Journals and Toolkits
  - Economic Benefits of Open Space
  - Economic Benefits of Outdoor Recreation And Tourism
  - Economic Benefits of Parks
  - Economic Impacts of Sprawl and Smart Growth
  - Economic Benefits of Trails
  - Economic Benefits of Urban Greenspace
  - Economic Benefits of Waterways and Wetlands
  - Economic Benefits of Working Lands
- Health Benefits of Conservation
- Environmental Benefits of Conservation
- Public Opinion Surveys & Polls
- Referenda Results
- Saving Land Saves Tax Dollars: Costs of Development & Conservation
  - Conducting Cost of Community Service Analyses
  - Costs of Community Services: Case Studies

Introduction to Land Trusts & Their Work

The Law
- Audits
- Eminent Domain & Takings
- Federal Tax Law
- Federal Law (non-tax)
- Liability Associated with Recreational Use
- Pennsylvania Statutes
- Pennsylvania Code
- Pennsylvania Case Law
- Case Law Review by Frone Crawford, Jr.
- Property Taxes

Landowner Resources
- Government Incentives
- Landowner Guides

Non-Regulatory Government Options
- CREP & Riparian Buffers
- General Resources for Government

Natural Gas
- June 2008 Conference Presentations
- Natural Gas Guidance
- Natural Gas Leases
- Natural Gas Websites & Blogs

Organizational Development & Management
- Advocacy & Lobbying
- Collaboration and Mergers
- Communication Samples (brochures, annual reports, etc.)
- Ethics
- Fundraising & Marketing
- Nonprofit Management
- Sample Bylaws
- Land Trust Standards and Practices
- Strategic Plans/Work Plans

Municipal Parks & Recreation

Trails & Greenways

Public Policy
- Working Papers
- State Conservation Tax Credits

Education & Communication
- Outreach Programs
- Curricula

Conference & Workshop Materials
- 2009 Pennsylvania Land Conservation Conference
- 2010 Pennsylvania Land Conservation Conference

Kittatinny Municipal Resources

Land Use Planning
- Technological Tools for Land Use Planning
- Design and Vision
  - Street and Transportation Design
- Land Use and Growth Management
- Build Out Analysis

Print Versions of ConservationTools.org Guides

Miscellaneous

Author: Nancy A. McLaughlin & Mark Benjamin Machlis
Org./Source: Utah Law Review
Year: 2008

McLaughlin and Machlis offer a rebuttal to Gerald Korngold’s article “Solving the Contentious Issues of Private Conservation Easements: Promoting Flexibility for the Future and Engaging the Public Land Use Process”, which presents a critique of conservation easements and a variety of suggestions for reform. They discuss five misconceptions that tend to pervade the criticism of conservation easements and result in proposals for reform that would be contrary to the public interest. They also discuss three of the primary reforms suggested in Korngold’s article and why they feel those reforms are both unnecessary and inadvisable.

Files for Download or Pages for Viewing

Protecting_the_Public_Interest_and_Investments_in_Conservation.pdf (353.0 KB)

Item type(s): Law Journal Articles
Topic tags: Conservation Easements

Last modified by Elana Richman

Comments

Viewed 307 times.
Last modified Nov 11, 2010

Suggest changes to this item

Thanks to George Asimos for supporting this website. Thanks also to the PA Department of Conservation and Natural Resources. Photos courtesy of Wildlands Conservancy / T.L. Gettings.

This website is for general information only and is not intended to provide legal advice or legal opinion. Those who contribute information to the site assume no responsibility for errors and omissions or any liability for damages resulting from use of the material here. This site is maintained by the Pennsylvania Land Trust Association.

Conservation Tools